She did it, despite being a woman - Instablogs
She did it, despite being a woman
Virag Dhulia , Bangalore: Feb 21 2009
Made Popular Feb 24 2009
India :

She did it, despite being a woman
“She did it, despite being a woman”, have we not heard this statement quite often. It has been so deeply engrained in our thoughts and psyches that whenever we see a woman performing, this statement, which will be henceforth called as Dialogue, comes out as a de-facto behavioral pattern. And this pattern has far reaching implications which we will see in this article.
The Dialogue generates a lot of sympathy for the women folk and the girl, who did it, despite being a woman, definitely feels good because for sure, the dialogue has a motivational and lauding tenure. However, it demeans the women folk in general and imbibes a feeling in them that they need to do something extra-ordinary to get recognized whereas the males can get away with ordinary performance. But this view is again only a perception and not a reality. In reality, girls are encouraged even if they achieve anything small, whereas boys do not have that luxury.
The dialogue reflects a general sentiment that women are inferior and need extra-motivation to perform. Also it reflects that since women are weaker, apparently, they need to be given concessions. However this again is a perception and not a reality. In general, the society has an overwhelming tendency to pamper women and this dialogue is the result of Women Pamperment.
Let us take some real life examples. The very recently popular TV Show, the Indian Idol is running its fourth season. And Sonali Bendre, one of the judges openly says that this time she wants a girl to be an Indian Idol, because the last the idols have been boys. It is unbecoming of a judge of a talent based show to make such a statement. The dialogue as mentioned, actually tries to engenderize the issue.
Nature does not distribute its talent based on gender. Every single individual is talented and this fact needs to be respected. However, since feminists wanted to run their shop of selling women rights, they propagated such memes in the society like, “She did it, despite being a woman”. It actually bogs down the entire womanhood and any self-respecting woman would condemn such an attitude.
I cannot help, but quote Chanda Kochar, the CEO of ICICI Bank here. In a recent TV interview she was asked, “Is it not a fact that you need to be 2 times better than others to be here?” The reply she gave was, “The CEO of the largest private sector bank definitely needs to be 2 times better than her peers.” But the dialogue does not go with it, since the merchants of the dialogue always want it to be associated with every woman’s achievement since they use this dialogue to draw further concessions for women from the society.
As a matter of fact, gender has got to do absolutely nothing with performance and such dialogues should be discouraged because women are equally competent and do not need any extra concession or motivation to perform or achieve. She did it, because she can, not because she is a woman.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
Steven Gary
melbourne, Australia
I agree with this article, and personally believe we are moving into the post femminist era where people are judged on merit abilities of character or skills, without politically prejudicing outcomes because of pre-supposed notions of being feminist savvy, which in actual fact in a reverse psychology sense -is patronising women.

Hopefully we are moving into equality without the patronising overcompensating notions of feminism. (which is demeaning and patronising)to intelligent women; but what the early advocates of womens rights wanted which was true equality and opportunity.

Also I dont think femminism as a movement for society is one mainstream philosophical dogma of politically correct notions, but more like an adapting and many ideas movement from varieties of women and articles like this, to define and redefine what eqality is and what are good reforms of thinking and approach and hopefully one day(soon)we will be in a post femminist world where equality will seem normal,people will look in the history books and say about the femminist era, and think there was funny things in the past.
1 Stars
Vikas Shekhawat instablogs.com
Churu, Rajasthan, India
Rightly said Virag. The ”dialogues” should stop now. However, only women can dilute the psyche. They only can change the current perceptions and make a solid dent by grabbing more and more opportunities.
1 Stars
Rudra Bhaumik
kolkata, India
yes Virag!!
”She did it, because she can, not because she is a woman.” Why we should give women extra credit for same achievement??
1 Stars
Shikha Garg
Meerut/Delhi, India
I partially agree with you Virag. Things vary according to situations and so do the dialogues. This statement might go well enough in a metroploitan city but can’t always work in rural India. Most of the time ’she’ is prohibited to take up something like photography as a course of her study or may be being a driver just becuase she is a woman. In this case, I feel, that ’she did it, because she WANTED TO PROVE HERSELF and not because she can’ There are lots of examples in our day-to-day lives. This motivational dialogue, i feel, works well to motivate women in rural India. For the rest we are equal and we don’t need any support as of our gender. We should be treated for what we do and not for what we are.
Add your Comment